Secret Canadian Health
Ministry Memo Shows Influence of Prohibitionist Ideologues:
"The use of marijuana for medicinal purposes could
send the wrong message to Canadian teenagers"
May 8, 1999
From The Calgary Herald
letters@theherald.southam.ca
http://www.calgaryherald.com/
By Jim Bronskill DOUBTS ON MEDICAL USE OF POT
Allowing the use of marijuana for medicinal purposes could
send the wrong message to Canadian teenagers, sparking greater acceptance of the drug,
warns an internal Health Department memo.
(Marijuananews note: The Calgary Herald seems to take the memo at face value. However,
the real significance of the memo is that it demonstrates the degree to which second rate
prohibitionist arguments may have delayed access to medical marijuana. Perhaps this
thinking is the reason why even now the government refuses to provide patients with a
legal source of medical marijuana.
See
Canadian
Patients Can Apply For Medical Use Of Marijuana, But There's Still No Legal Source.
-- "Its unfair. Its just patently unfair," Says Superior Court
Justice.
"Im sick. Im scared. I need help not harassment." Says AIDS Patient
Notice that it leads with the "sends the wrong message" line, a really
ridiculous argument.)
The concern is one of a litany of thorny issues raised by federal officials in the newly
released briefing document, which examines the potential use of marijuana for therapeutic
purposes.
The note, prepared by the departments health protection
branch for minister Allan Rock, identifies several stumbling blocks, including
health hazards posed by cannabis, possible friction with the medical profession and the
difficulty of obtaining legal supplies of the drug.
An edited version of the memo, originally stamped secret,
was obtained by Southam News under the Access to Information Act.
(Marijuananews note: One hopes that it was "stamped secret" because of
embarrassment.)
The department cites United Nations research that indicates the age of initiation into
drug abuse has been falling yearly. "The rate of drug use among young people is
linked to their perception of risks related to drugs," says the memo. "The use of marijuana as a therapeutic product may convey the false message
that marijuana has some benefit and is not that dangerous."
(Marijuananews note: "The false message that marijuana has some benefit"?
See
Chairman of
the House of Lords Science and Technology Committee
Criticizes UK Governments Rejection Of Report On Medical Marijuana
2 Articles With 2 of the Worst Prohibitionist Arguments
If it has no benefit, then that argument should be made, not the absurdly illogical
argument that having medical benefit indicates that a drug is "not that
dangerous." Many very valuable drugs are very dangerous.)
See
They Are Legal, So They Must Be Safe:
"Teens Abusing Drugstore Medicines"
Should We Have Drug-Free Drugstores?
Context For Medical Marijuana and "Drug Education" Debates
and
Marijuana, Caffeine,
Thalidomide and the Persecution of the Sick and Dying
It notes several "hazardous effects" of marijuana, including short-term
impairment of motor skills, increased blood pressure, lung damage, suppression of the
immune system and risk of dependence among heavy users.
The memo suggests government efforts to stamp out smoking and to combat illegal drug
use could be undermined by making marijuana available for medical use, saying the move
"may be in conflict with the Canadian drug and tobacco strategies."
Canada is a signatory to a series of international treaties that require the federal
government to exercise control over production and distribution of narcotics, including
marijuana. "Any movement towards legal access to marijuana may
be perceived negatively by other countries."
(Marijuananews note: My, my! I wonder what "other countries" they may have in
mind. If this was a secret memo it should have dealt candidly with DEAland pressure.
Perhaps it did, and that was the part that was edited out.)
The federal government has come under pressure in recent years to allow sufferers of
AIDS and cancer to smoke marijuana to cope with nausea caused by chemical therapies.
(Marijuananews note: Not to mention pressure from people with MS,
chronic pain, etc. Why would they do that, if it has no medical value?)
|