The House of Lords Press
Release On Medical Marijuana; Medical, Yes; Legalization, No
(Marijuananews note: I will have some analysis
on this soon, but I wanted to get it posted.)November 11, 1998
The House of Lords, Science and Technology Committee (UK)
Contact: Fax: +0171-219 6715 or 0171-219 4931
Mail: Science and Technology Committee, House of Lords, London, SW1A 0PW
http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/ld/ldhome.htm
LORDS SAY, LEGALISE CANNABIS FOR MEDICAL USE
The Government should allow doctors to prescribe cannabis for medical use:
this is the conclusion of a report by the House of Lords Science and Technology
Committee, published today.
Lord Perry of Walton, chairman of the inquiry said: "We have seen enough evidence
to convince us that a doctor might legitimately want to prescribe cannabis to relieve
pain, or the symptoms of multiple sclerosis (MS), and that the criminal law ought not to
stand in the way. Far from being a step towards general legalisation, our recommendation
would make the ban on recreational use easier to enforce. Above all, it would show
compassion to patients who currently risk prosecution to get help."
MEDICAL USE
Cannabis is a "Schedule 1" drug, and cannot be used at all in medicine,
except for research under special Home Office licence. The Lords recommend that it should
be moved to "Schedule 2". This would allow doctors to prescribe it, subject to
certain special regulations, and it would allow doctors and pharmacists to supply it in
accordance with a prescription.
The report sets out evidence that cannabis can be effective in some patients to relieve
the symptoms of MS, and against certain forms of pain. The Lords say, this evidence is
enough to justify a change in the law. They are less convinced about its effectiveness in
other conditions, including epilepsy, glaucoma and asthma.
The Lords welcome the fact that clinical trials of cannabis are currently being
launched, by the Royal Pharmaceutical Society, and by Dr Geoffrey Guy of GW
Pharmaceuticals, with a view to the eventual licensing of cannabis as a medicine. The
Lords say, however, that cannabis should be rescheduled now, rather than waiting several
years for the results of these trials.
If cannabis ever becomes a licensed medicine, the Lords do not envisage it being
licensed for smoking; they call for research into alternative delivery systems.
At present, people who use cannabis for medical reasons risk prosecution; and juries
sometimes refuse to convict such people, which brings the law into disrepute. If
prescription were legalised, then someone using cannabis for medical reasons who was
accused of recreational use could clear himself at once by producing the prescription.
[More]
RECREATIONAL USE
The Lords find enough evidence of toxic effects of cannabis to justify maintaining the
present ban on recreational use. Besides being intoxicating, they report that:
NOTES FOR EDITORS
1. The report follows an inquiry which began in April, and included 12 public
hearings. A list of the Lords who took part in the study is attached :
2. The report is published by The Stationery Office: Cannabis, HL Paper 151, ISBN 0 10
4151986, £9.50.
3. The evidence taken by the Committee is published separately as HL Paper 151-I, ISBN
0 10 4792981, £22.60.
4. The full text will be on the Internet on publication, accessible via the UK
Parliament home page at www.parliament.uk
4. The Government are required to respond in writing to the report; and the report
will be debated in the House of Lords.
Further information from Elaine Morgan/Tessa Perfect
House of Lords Committee Office
Phone 0171-219 6075; Fax 0171-219 4931
CHAIRMAN
Lord Perry of Walton FRS (Lib Dem): former Professor of Pharmacology; founding
Vice-Chancellor of the Open University 1969-81.
MEMBERS
Lord Butterfield (Cons): Vice-Chancellor of Nottingham University 1970-75;
Regius Professor of Physic (ie medicine), Cambridge, 1975-87;
Vice-Chancellor of Cambridge University 1983-85.
Lord Butterworth (Cons): Vice-Chancellor of the University of Warwick 1963-85.
Lord Carmichael of Kelvingrove (Lab): MP 1962-83; former junior Minister in various
departments.
Lord Dixon-Smith (Cons): former Chairman, Association of County Councils.
Lord Kirkwood (Lib Dem): metallurgist; former lecturer, Sheffield University.
Lord Nathan (cross-bench): solicitor; former member of Royal Commission on
Environmental Pollution.
Lord Porter of Luddenham (cross-bench): Nobel Prize for Chemistry 1967;
President of the Royal Society 1985-90.
Lord Rea (Lab): former GP.
Lord Soulsby of Swaffham Prior (Cons): Emeritus Professor of Animal Pathology,
Cambridge; President of the Royal Society of Medicine.
Lord Walton of Detchant (cross-bench): former professor of Neurology and Dean of
Medicine, Newcastle University; former President of the General Medical Council, the
British Medical Association, and the World Federation of Neurology.
Lord Winston (Lab): Dean of the Institute of Obstetrics and Gynaecology.